Summary: Robinson Statement on Integrity Commissioner Sanction

Source: Statement from Councillor Lisa Robinson (Pickering) responding to the council sanction against her.

Core Claim

Robinson says a complaint by Councillors Brenner, Cook, and Nagy misrepresented three of her motions, and that the Integrity Commissioner adopted rather than corrected those misrepresentations.

The Three Disputed Motions

• Change rooms: She says her motion added an option for non-members to use existing male/female change rooms — it did not remove the universal change room.
• Flags: Her motion proposed a general policy limiting flagpoles to government flags (with Poppy/Veterans exceptions) — she says it was not aimed specifically at Pride or Trans flags.
• Events: Her motion proposed age restrictions on certain performances — she says it was not a proposal to end Pride or LGBTQ+ programming.

Allegations Against the Integrity Commissioner

• Used speculative language (“rings hollow,” “disingenuous”) rather than direct evidence.
• Labeled her conduct “homophobic” and “transphobic” without identifying hateful statements.
• Treated her giving out a business card and sitting near certain people as suspicious.
• Did not cite interviews with security staff or other direct witnesses.

Allegations About the Council Process

• Council allegedly voted without seeing her full written defence.
• The three complainant-councillors were allowed to vote on her sanction.
• Mayor Ashe allegedly privately recruited councillors to move/second the sanction motions before the public meeting, and restricted her questioning of the Commissioner during the meeting.

On the Judicial Review

Robinson clarifies that the Ontario Superior Court review addressed legal process and authority questions, not whether the underlying factual allegations were true.

Her Ask

She is releasing supporting documents (motions, complaint, report, video) for the public to compare directly, and says she will release evidence of the alleged behind-the-scenes coordination.

Framing Note

This is Robinson’s own account and characterization of events. It names Brenner, Cook, Nagy, Ashe, and the Integrity Commissioner and makes serious allegations (collusion, fabrication) against them. None of this is independently verified within the document, and the other parties’ side is not presented here.

___________