PICKERING: Rationale explaining Pickering Property tax situation

Rationale — why Pickering’s average residential property tax is reasonable compared with neighbours

Summary conclusion: Pickering’s combined residential tax rate (about 1.288% in 2025) is slightly lower than neighbouring Ajax and Whitby and noticeably lower than Oshawa’s. However, Pickering’s average assessed home value is higher than some neighbours (so dollar bills can end up similar), and recent modest municipal increases reflect region-wide levies and service needs. Taken together, the level and recent change in Pickering taxes are reasonable compared with neighbouring communities.

Key facts (2025 municipal data)

• Pickering total residential tax rate (combined municipal + region + education) — 0.01288240 (1.28824%) for residential class. City of Pickering
• Pickering’s 2025 city portion increase was 1.15%, which — together with Durham Region and school board changes — resulted in an average 5.26% increase on the total tax bill for the average Pickering home ($586,000 assessed value). Let’s Talk Pickering
• Whitby’s published 2025 total residential tax rate and example bill: Whitby shows an average 2025 residential tax bill of $6,700 on a property assessed at $503,000, with the Region portion about 55% of that bill. Town of Whitby
• Oshawa’s 2025 combined residential tax rate is higher (about 1.524475% total). City of Oshawa
• Ajax’s 2025 tax materials show a total levy and published increases in a similar range to other Durham municipalities. (Ajax tax by-law / PDF available for 2025 detail). ajax.ca+1

Why those facts make Pickering’s taxes reasonable

1. Rate vs. neighbours: Pickering’s total tax rate (≈1.288%) is slightly lower than Whitby/Ajax (both around ~1.33%–1.34% in 2025 data) and substantially lower than Oshawa (≈1.52%). That places Pickering in the lower-to-middle tier of Durham municipalities on a percentage-rate basis, which supports the idea that its tax burden is not unusually high. City of Pickering+2WOWA+2
2. Assessment (dollars) matters more than percentage: Property tax dollars paid = assessed value × total tax rate. Pickering’s average assessed home used in budget communications ($586,000) is higher than Whitby’s example ($503,000). So even with a slightly lower rate, a Pickering homeowner can pay a comparable or larger dollar amount than a Whitby homeowner — this explains why rate comparisons alone can mislead unless you look at assessed values. Let’s Talk Pickering+1
3. Regional share and school boards reduce city control: A large portion of the final bill is the Region of Durham levy and provincial education portion. Pickering’s municipal portion increased only modestly (1.15% in 2025); most of the larger total increase reported by residents is driven by the Region and school board levies. That’s a common pattern across neighbouring municipalities and makes Pickering’s municipal decisions look conservative in context. Let’s Talk Pickering+1
4. Service and infrastructure drivers are comparable: Pickering, Ajax, Whitby and Oshawa all face similar pressures — population growth, transit and roads, regional services, and inflationary cost pressures. Pickering’s modest municipal levy increase and mid-range total rate indicate it is aligning revenue with those pressures without being an outlier. (Durham Region publishes annual studies and tax strategies showing similar drivers across the region.) Durham+1
5. Transparency and published data: Pickering publishes its tax rates, budget highlights, and tax-rate bylaw (2025 PDF) — allowing direct comparison. That transparency and the city’s communication about how much of the increase is municipal vs. regional supports the reasonableness argument. City of Pickering+1

Short caveat / nuance

• Comparisons change with reassessments and market shifts. If assessed values fluctuate differently across municipalities, dollar comparisons will change even if rates stay the same. The provincial education rate is fixed but municipal and regional levies can vary year to year, so yearly comparisons should use the most recent bylaws and assessment figures. (Municipal pages and regional studies are the best sources for those yearly changes.) City of Pickering+1

One-sentence conclusion

On a percentage-rate basis Pickering is slightly cheaper than its immediate neighbours (Ajax/Whitby) and well below Oshawa; when you factor in higher average assessments in Pickering the dollar bills can be similar — overall, Pickering’s 2025 residential property-tax position is reasonable and not an outlier within Durham Region.

________

RETURN to previous article